The Boxer With Baez and Simon: A Narrative Interrupted by a Refrain

“The Boxer” alternates between telling a story and returning to a refrain that does not depend on another set of narrative sentences. Joan Baez and Paul Simon’s performance at her 75th birthday celebration offers a focused way to hear that distinction. The repeated material gives the listener a familiar place to return while the verses move through a changing account.

PBS identifies the celebration at New York’s Beacon Theatre in 2016. The occasion explains the public collaboration, while the song’s form supplies a listening subject beyond the fact that two recognizable artists share the stage.

▶Play performance video

The verses accumulate information

Simon’s published text begins from the position of someone recounting hardship and departure. The narrative introduces places, work, loneliness, and the pull of home before shifting toward the image of a boxer. These details build a world rather than simply repeating the title’s idea.

A listener can follow the movement of that account without treating it as a literal autobiography of either person singing. The narrator belongs to the composition. A performer gives that position a voice, but does not automatically become the subject of every event described.

For the duet, follow the continuity of the account across the performers’ contributions. The useful question is what carries the narrative forward, not whether the apparent speaker changes each time the featured voice changes.

The refrain does another kind of work

A nonlexical refrain can be recognizable without adding another factual event to the story. It creates a musical return, giving a listener an opportunity to experience the accumulated narrative from a familiar point.

That makes its repetition different from repeating a summary sentence. The sound can carry continuity and emotional emphasis without telling the audience exactly how to interpret every verse. A shared performance can also make that return feel collective even when the narrative has been carried through an individual voice.

Notice whether your attention changes when the refrain arrives. You may stop following new information and begin anticipating a known musical course. The contrast between those activities is part of the song’s construction.

Another song makes the contrast clearer

The related “Here Comes the Sun” performance with Simon, David Crosby, and Graham Nash changes the composition. It offers a work whose recurring title phrase communicates verbally as well as musically, rather than relying on the same kind of nonlexical return.

▶Play performance video

Compare the function of returning material, not merely the number of singers. In each song, consider what becomes familiar and what information continues to develop around it.

Hold the second song and change the partnership

The final selection pairs Simon with George Harrison on “Here Comes the Sun.” That keeps the second composition in place while altering the performing relationship.

▶Play performance video

This creates two separate comparisons: different songs organize their returns differently, and different partnerships can interpret the same song. Keeping those questions apart prevents every shared performance from becoming an interchangeable example of harmony.

Returning to Baez and Simon’s “The Boxer” makes its particular design easier to hear. Narrative detail draws the listener onward, while the refrain provides recognition without another explanatory sentence. The duet realizes that relationship inside a specific celebration, allowing the composition to remain as substantial a presence as the performers.