“Four Elphabas” describes a performance opportunity, not a change to the population of Oz. In Official London Theatre’s Musical Con 2022 video, several interpreters are brought together around music associated with one role. That distinction makes the number more interesting: the audience can hear the shared identity of a song while considering what remains individual about its delivery.
“Defying Gravity” belongs to Wicked, with music and lyrics by Stephen Schwartz and a book by Winnie Holzman. A convention performance extracts the song from the full production and gives it another purpose: celebrating a role and the performers who have interpreted it.
Watch on YouTube ↗
A role is a framework, not a single voice
A theatrical role includes a place in a story, relationships, words, and musical material. An actor supplies an interpretation within that framework. When several performers share one role’s song, differences need not imply disagreement about the character. They can reflect distinct choices about emphasis, tone, and the direction of a phrase.
Listen for continuity as carefully as contrast. Which features keep the number recognizable as the same work? Where does an individual voice become particularly easy to distinguish? If a line passes between singers, consider what the handover does to the phrase’s momentum rather than assuming that each singer represents a separate fictional person.
This also changes how a viewer might respond to the word “best.” A concert collaboration does not have to function as an audition or a ranking. It can expose several valid approaches to the same dramatic material without declaring one approach the only way the role should sound.
The missing scene still matters
A song heard within a musical follows earlier events and leads toward later ones. Removed from that sequence, it can become an anthem, a showcase, or a shared celebration. Those uses are related, but they are not interchangeable explanations of the original scene.
A practical listening distinction is to ask two questions separately: what decision is the character making, and what kind of occasion are these performers creating? The first concerns the drama. The second concerns the concert. Keeping both in view prevents the number’s broad public associations from swallowing its theatrical purpose.
Watch on YouTube ↗
Anniversary presentation and cast recording
The anniversary edition supplies another official presentation of the number. Its value beside the convention video is not that it must be the definitive version, but that it shows how a musical can revisit its own repertoire for a commemorative setting. A song can preserve its identity while its presentation changes.
Watch on YouTube ↗
The original Broadway cast recording provides a different reference again: a recorded document associated with the show’s original production. Listen for the organization of the number and its progression, then return to the multiple-performer version. The comparison is clearer when it names the formats rather than treating all three uploads as one production.
Try a brief note with three headings: character, interpreter, and occasion. Under character, describe the dramatic decision. Under interpreter, identify one audible choice. Under occasion, note whether the recording is a convention performance, anniversary presentation, or cast album. Those three layers explain why four Elphabas can belong in one number without becoming four different characters.
