A songwriting tribute needs more than a room full of famous people. The selections must give those people something meaningful to perform and give listeners a way into the writer’s work. Three recordings from Paul McCartney’s 2010 White House concert offer three different answers: a refrain with room for many voices, a song associated with a single name and a duet built around two named performers.
The occasion was the Library of Congress Gershwin Prize for Popular Song. McCartney, its third recipient, received the award at the White House on June 2, 2010. The Library’s account separates that East Room concert from a related event at the Library the preceding day, a distinction worth preserving when identifying recordings from the celebration.
‘Hey Jude’: company through repetition
Watch on YouTube ↗
The official White House archive identifies Hey Jude as an East Room performance during the prize concert. Its presence in this selection provides a starting point for thinking about a familiar concert device: a repeated vocal ending can give an audience time to recognize a pattern and find a place within it.
Repetition is sometimes treated as the opposite of development. In a participatory section, however, the material can remain recognizable while its social function changes. A listener who initially follows the lead singer may later be able to contribute. Remembering a short repeated shape requires a different kind of attention from following a complete verse.
This helps explain why the ending of Hey Jude lends itself to a shared setting without requiring every participant to have equal musical responsibility. The lead performer can continue to guide the piece while others occupy a more limited part. Participation does not have to mean that everyone suddenly becomes a soloist.
‘Michelle’: a name connects song and occasion
The next recording is labeled Michelle at the same White House celebration. In the presence of First Lady Michelle Obama, the title offers an immediate connection between an existing song and the occasion. That connection belongs to the circumstances of this performance; it does not change the composition into a biography of its listener.
Watch on YouTube ↗
A dedication, an association and a literal subject are different things. A song can be offered to someone whose name it shares without having been written about that person. Keeping those ideas separate allows the moment to retain its charm without inventing a history for the writing.
It also offers a contrast with the earlier selection. A repeated communal section makes space broadly; a title can point attention toward a particular person. Both create a relationship between music and gathering, but they do so at different scales.
‘Ebony and Ivory’: two performers share the task
The third supplied recording pairs McCartney and Stevie Wonder for Ebony and Ivory. Here the social shape is explicit in the performance credit: two established artists share a named number. It is useful to distinguish that partnership from both audience participation and a title’s situational association.
Watch on YouTube ↗
In a duet, the question is how a musical statement can belong to two people. Alternation, joined material and the space left for a partner are possible resources, rather than a requirement that every line receive an identical division. Following the relationship is more revealing than simply counting famous voices.
An award concert designed to travel
The Library of Congress records that the program was produced for PBS and broadcast on July 28, 2010. The televised presentation made an event with a particular invited gathering available to people elsewhere. The current clips extend that change of audience again: viewers arrive at individual songs, often without the whole program surrounding them.
Watching the selections together restores some of that larger shape. Hey Jude opens the idea of company outward, Michelle makes an occasion-specific connection, and Ebony and Ivory concentrates on partnership. The prize recognizes a songwriter; the songs provide distinct ways for other people to enter the celebration.
